Schleicher's Fable - Revision history

Admin at 19:18, 31 October 2017

2017-10-31T19:18:17Z

Admin at 16:16, 31 October 2017

2017-10-31T16:16:56Z

Admin at 10:06, 31 October 2017

2017-10-31T10:06:43Z

Admin at 21:02, 30 October 2017

2017-10-30T21:02:33Z

Admin at 19:58, 30 October 2017

2017-10-30T19:58:24Z

Admin: Created page with "

'''North-West Indo-European''' ¹ ó'''u̯is''' é'''ku̯ōs'''-kʷe, ² ó'..."

2017-10-30T19:52:23Z

Created page with "<div class="row"> <div class="small-6 column"> '''North-West Indo-European''' 1 ó'''u̯is''' é'''ku̯ōs'''-kʷe, 2 ó'..."

New page

<div class="row">
<div class="small-6 column">
'''North-West Indo-European'''

1 ó'''u̯is''' é'''ku̯ōs'''-kʷe,

2 ó'''u̯is''' '''i̯ós'''mi u̯ĺ̥'''nā''' né '''est''';

3 é'''ku̯ons''' de'''dór'''ke,

4 tom gʷr̥h'''u̯úm''' u̯ó'''gʰom''' u̯é'''gʰon'''tm̥,

5 tom mé'''gām''' bʰó'''rom''',

6 tom '''''dʰ''gʰmón'''m̥ '''ō'''kú bʰé'''ron'''tm̥.,

7 ó'''u̯is''' éku̯o'''bʰos''' u̯eu'''kʷét''':

8 “kērd ágʰnu'''tor''' moi,

9 '''''dʰ''gʰmón'''m̥ é'''ku̯ons''' á'''gon'''tm̥ u̯idn̥'''téi'''”

10 é'''ku̯ōs''' u̯eu'''kʷónt''': “kl̥'''néu''', ó'''u̯i'''!

11 kērd ágʰnu'''tor''' nos u̯idn̥t'''bʰós''':

12 ''dʰ''gʰmōn, pó'''tis''', ó'''u̯i̯os''' u̯ĺ̥'''nām'''

13 sé'''bʰei''' '''gʷʰór'''mom '''u̯és'''trom kʷr̥'''néu'''ti.

14 ó'''u̯i̯om'''-kʷe u̯ĺ̥'''nā''' né '''es'''ti”.

15 Tod keklu'''u̯ṓs''' ó'''u̯is''' á'''grom''' bʰu'''gét'''.

</div>
<div class="small-6 column">

'''English'''

1 The sheep and the horses.

2 A sheep that had no wool

3 saw horses;

4 one pulling a heavy wagon,

5 one carrying a big load,

6 one carrying a man quickly.

7 The sheep said to the horses:

8 “My heart pains me,

9 seeing a man driving horses.”

10 The horses said: “Listen, sheep!

11 Our hearts pain us when we see this:

12 A man, the master, makes the wool of the sheep

13 into a warm garment for himself.

14 And the sheep has no wool.”

15 Having heard this, the sheep fled into the plain
</div>

A recitation of the text is available on [https://youtu.be/_6ne-xvC0TU Youtube].

{{#evt:
service=youtube
|id=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6ne-xvC0TU
|alignment=center
}}

Certain potentially controversial selections have been made:

* As in other tonal languages<ref>Just like Mandarin Chinese, PIE must have had both stress and pitch accent. Both were important, since some syllables must have had more prominence than others, and high pitch seems to have been more prominent – vowel length appears in most Anatolian words on PIE stressed syllable[DeLisi 2013]. As a rule of thumb – as e.g. in the reconstructed Ancient Greek pronunciation, in Arabic, or in the Sezer stress pattern in Turkish –, syllable weight (the length of the syllable) marks the stress of words in this rendition of the fable. Whenever possible, then, syllables that include a long vowel or a diphthong (CVV) and those with more than one consonant (CVCC) are stressed. If in conflict, those with a combination of both (CVVCC) are probably the stressed ones.</ref>, stress accent has been placed on heavy syllables during recitation, and these are marked in bold.

*For laryngeals and vocalism, see below. For *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' < **''h2/3u̯ĺ̥h1-neh2'', two possible results in NWIE were *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' / *''uhlā́nā''. Because of O.Ind. ''ū́rṇā''-, a pronunciation *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' is selected.

*For *''eku̯ons'', probably from an older **''eku̯o-m-s'' formed by the accusative singular ending *-''m'' and plural ending *-''s'', cf. *-''ms'' in Anatolian[Kloekhorst 2008]. An older form for ‘horse’ is found in Anatolian **''eku-m-s'', cf. Hitt. ekku-[Kortlandt 2013] – the likely general development in LIE (and certainly in NWIE) has been selected, though.

* *''dedórke'' carries the accent on the root, as usually reconstructed following Indo-Iranian examples[Kümmel et al. 2001]. The alternative *''dédorke'' is also possible. The more commonly reconstructed term for the fable, *''woide'', originally a perfect of *''weid''-, ‘see’, had already by LIE adopted a slightly different meaning, ‘know’, potentially from a previous ‘state derived of having seen’ (?).

*The accusative *''tom'' has been used, instead of the nominative *''so'', because they are the objects (acc. *''éku̯ons'') seen. However, the use of nominative *''so'' would also be right, especially from a historical point of view, when it was not yet inflected – like uninflected *''i'' instead of *''i̯ós''-[Kortlandt 2010].

* *''mégā'' has been declined following LIE and NWIE examples, although it has been proposed that it was indeclinable in earlier times[Pooth 2017].

*For *''dʰgʰmon''-: There seems to be a trend toward simplification of the initial phoneme in this cluster in NWIE, hence the pronunciation *''gʰmon''-; cf. O.Lat. ''hemō'' (Osc. ''humuns'', Umbr. ''homonus''), Gmc. *''gum-an-'', Bal. *''ǯmō̃'' (O. Lith. ''žmuõ'', O. Pruss. ''smoy''). A different reduction is found in O.Ir. duine < *''don-i̯os'', probably from metathesised form *''gdon-i̯os'' < **''gʰdʰmon-i̯os''.

**The other common LIE word used to translate ‘man’ in the fable, *''ner''-, is not used here because of its more specialised use in NWIE as ‘manly, strong’ mainly in archaisms, cf. Italo-Celtic *''ner''- (as Lat. ''neriōsus'', O.Ir. ''nert''), Gmc. *''ner''- (OHG ''Nerthus''), Bal. *''ner-/nor-'' (Lith. ''Nertėti'', O.Pruss. ''nertien'').

*Obliques in *-''bh''- have been used, following the Italo-Celtic and Graeco-Aryan examples, against *-''m''- found in Germanic and Balto-Slavic, which is potentially influenced by a common substrate to both languages (see [[Corded Ware substrate hypothesis]]). The pronunciation of *-''bh''- in *u̯idn̥tbhós seems to be compelled by the preceding *-''t''- to be in *-''phos'' or *-''ɸos'', although an effort is made to pronounce it in a phonemically correct way.

*Aorists are reconstructed without augment in *''é-'', proper of Graeco-Aryan[Meier-Brügger 2003].

*Nominative *''kērd'' is reconstructed with a *-''d'' at the end, although it was possibly mute[Ringe 2006].

*Middle-passives are reconstructed in *-''r'', following the generalised belief of its older nature – as a primary ending in Anatolian and Tocharian –, and its reconstruction for Italo-Celtic, as well as remains with impersonal value in Germanic.

*For present stem *''kl̥néu''-/''kl̥nu''-, ‘hear’, cf. O.Ir. ''ro-cluinethar'', Toch. B ''kalneṃ'', A ''kälniñc'', and also Skt. ''śr̥ṇóti'', Av. ''surunaoiti''. For verbal stem *''klu''-, frequently used when reconstructing the fable, the original meaning appears to be ‘be named, be renown’, cf. Av. ''sruiiē'', ‘be famous’, Lat. ''clueō'', ‘be named, be famous’, S.Picene ''kduíú'', ‘be named’[Kümmel et al. 2001]. The optional imperative suffix *-''dhí'' is not used.

*Voiced consonants at the end of syllable (such as *-''d'', *-''gh''-, etc.) are pronounced voiced, because LIE or NWIE did not have final obstruent devoicing as a rule[Byrd 2010]. However, there are certain known cases of regressive assimilation, such as *DT→*TT, hence *''tod'' in the last sentence may be more exactly pronounced as *''tot-kekluu̯ṓs''.

*We have selected the form *''ágros''[Ringe 2006][Nikolaev 2009] over the more ‘traditional’ *''agrós''.

== References ==

* [*Byrd 2010] Byrd, Andrew Miles. 2010. Reconstructing Indo-European Syllabification, Linguistics Faculty, University of California, Los Angeles.

* [*DeLisi 2013] DeLisi, Jessica. 2013. Notes on Indo-European Linguistics. In Derived primarily from lecture notes from Indo-European Phonology, Morphology, and Syntax classes taught at UCLA by H. Craig Melchert and Brent Vine from 2008-2009.

* [*Kloekhorst 2008] Kloekhorst, Alwin. 2008. Etymological Dictionary of the Hittite Inherited Lexicon. Edited by A. Lubotsky, Leiden Indo-European Etymological Dictionary Series. Leiden / Boston: Brill.

* [*Kortlandt 2010] Kortlandt, Frederik. 2010. Studies in Germanic, Indo-European and Indo-Uralic. Amsterdam/New York: Rodopi.

* [*Kortlandt 2013] Repeated Author. 2013. Schleicher's fable edited by L. University.

* [*Kümmel et al. 2001] Kümmel, M., Th. Zehnder, R. Lipp, and B. Schirmer. 2001. Lexikon der indogermanischen Verben. Die Wurzeln und ihre Primärstammbildungen (LIV). Wiesbaden: Dr. Ludwig Reichert Verlag.

* [*Meier-Brügger 2003] Meier-Brügger, Michael. 2003. Indo-European Linguistics. Berlin, New York: Walter de Gruyter.

* [*Nikolaev 2009] Nikolaev, Alexander. 2009. The Germanic word for ‘sword’ and delocatival derivation in Proto-Indo-European. Journal of Indo-European Studies 37 (3/4):461-488.

* [*Pooth 2017] Pooth, Roland A. 2017. Proto-Indo-European Nominal Morphology. Part 2. Adjectives. Language Arts 5 (version 2017 APR 21).

* [*Ringe 2006] Ringe, D. 2006. A Linguistic History of English: Volume I, From Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic. Oxford Scholarship Online, 2006. Edited by D. Ringe. 2 vols. Vol. 1, A Linguistic History of English. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

<HarvardReferences />

==Notes==
<references />

@@ Line 68: / Line 68: @@
 <small><sup>15</sup></small> Having heard this, the sheep fled into the plain
 </div>
+</div>
 A recitation of the text is available on [https://youtu.be/_6ne-xvC0TU Youtube].

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:06, 31 October 2017
Line 93:		Line 93:

	For ''dʰgʰmon''-: There seems to be a trend toward simplification of the initial phoneme in this cluster in NWIE, hence the pronunciation ''gʰmon''-; cf. O.Lat. ''hemō'' (Osc. ''humuns'', Umbr. ''homonus''), Gmc. ''gum-an-'', Bal. ''ǯmō̃'' (O. Lith. ''žmuõ'', O. Pruss. ''smoy''). A different reduction is found in O.Ir. duine < ''don-i̯os'', probably from metathesised form ''gdon-i̯os'' < *''gʰdʰmon-i̯os''.		For ''dʰgʰmon''-: There seems to be a trend toward simplification of the initial phoneme in this cluster in NWIE, hence the pronunciation ''gʰmon''-; cf. O.Lat. ''hemō'' (Osc. ''humuns'', Umbr. ''homonus''), Gmc. ''gum-an-'', Bal. ''ǯmō̃'' (O. Lith. ''žmuõ'', O. Pruss. ''smoy''). A different reduction is found in O.Ir. duine < ''don-i̯os'', probably from metathesised form ''gdon-i̯os'' < *''gʰdʰmon-i̯os''.
−
	** The other common LIE word used to translate ‘man’ in the fable, ''ner''-, is not used here because of its more specialised use in NWIE as ‘manly, strong’ mainly in archaisms, cf. Italo-Celtic ''ner''- (as Lat. ''neriōsus'', O.Ir. ''nert''), Gmc. ''ner''- (OHG ''Nerthus''), Bal. ''ner-/nor-'' (Lith. ''Nertėti'', O.Pruss. ''nertien'').		** The other common LIE word used to translate ‘man’ in the fable, ''ner''-, is not used here because of its more specialised use in NWIE as ‘manly, strong’ mainly in archaisms, cf. Italo-Celtic ''ner''- (as Lat. ''neriōsus'', O.Ir. ''nert''), Gmc. ''ner''- (OHG ''Nerthus''), Bal. ''ner-/nor-'' (Lith. ''Nertėti'', O.Pruss. ''nertien'').

@@ Line 68: / Line 68: @@
 <small><sup>15</sup></small> Having heard this, the sheep fled into the plain
 </div>
 A recitation of the text is available on [https://youtu.be/_6ne-xvC0TU Youtube].

@@ Line 70: / Line 70: @@
 </div>
-A recitation of the text is available on [https://youtu.be/_6ne-xvC0TU Youtube].
+A recitation of the text is available on [https://youtu.be/_6ne-xvC0TU Youtube] and [https://www.facebook.com/indoeuropean/videos/10155099599571313/ Facebook].
 {{#evt:
 service=youtube
 |id=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6ne-xvC0TU
 |alignment=center
 }}

@@ Line 81: / Line 81: @@
 * As in other tonal languages<ref>Just like Mandarin Chinese, PIE must have had both stress and pitch accent. Both were important, since some syllables must have had more prominence than others, and high pitch seems to have been more prominent – vowel length appears in most Anatolian words on PIE stressed syllable[DeLisi 2013]. As a rule of thumb – as e.g. in the reconstructed Ancient Greek pronunciation, in Arabic, or in the Sezer stress pattern in Turkish –, syllable weight (the length of the syllable) marks the stress of words in this rendition of the fable. Whenever possible, then, syllables that include a long vowel or a diphthong (CVV) and those with more than one consonant (CVCC) are stressed. If in conflict, those with a combination of both (CVVCC) are probably the stressed ones.</ref>, stress accent has been placed on heavy syllables during recitation, and these are marked in bold.
-*For laryngeals and vocalism, see below. For *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' < **''h<sub>2</sub>/<sub>3</sub>u̯ĺ̥h<sub>1</sub>-neh<sub>2</sub>'', two possible results in NWIE were *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' / *''uhlā́nā''.  Because of O.Ind. ''ū́rṇā''-, a pronunciation *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' is selected.
+*For laryngeals and vocalism, see below. For *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' < **''h₂/₃u̯ĺ̥h₁-neh₂'', two possible results in NWIE were *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' / *''uhlā́nā''.  Because of O.Ind. ''ū́rṇā''-, a pronunciation *''u̯ĺ̥nā'' is selected.
 *For *''eku̯ons'', probably from an older **''eku̯o-m-s'' formed by the accusative singular ending *-''m'' and plural ending *-''s'', cf. *-''ms'' in Anatolian[Kloekhorst 2008]. An older form for ‘horse’ is found in Anatolian **''eku-m-s'', cf. Hitt. ekku-[Kortlandt 2013] – the likely general development in LIE (and certainly in NWIE) has been selected, though.
@@ Line 93: / Line 93: @@
 *For *''dʰgʰmon''-: There seems to be a trend toward simplification of the initial phoneme in this cluster in NWIE, hence the pronunciation *''gʰmon''-; cf. O.Lat. ''hemō'' (Osc. ''humuns'', Umbr. ''homonus''), Gmc. *''gum-an-'', Bal. *''ǯmō̃'' (O. Lith. ''žmuõ'', O. Pruss. ''smoy''). A different reduction is found in O.Ir. duine < *''don-i̯os'', probably from metathesised form *''gdon-i̯os'' < **''gʰdʰmon-i̯os''.
-**The other common LIE word used to translate ‘man’ in the fable, *''ner''-, is not used here because of its more specialised use in NWIE as ‘manly, strong’ mainly in archaisms, cf. Italo-Celtic *''ner''- (as Lat. ''neriōsus'', O.Ir. ''nert''), Gmc. *''ner''- (OHG ''Nerthus''), Bal. *''ner-/nor-'' (Lith. ''Nertėti'', O.Pruss. ''nertien'').
+** The other common LIE word used to translate ‘man’ in the fable, *''ner''-, is not used here because of its more specialised use in NWIE as ‘manly, strong’ mainly in archaisms, cf. Italo-Celtic *''ner''- (as Lat. ''neriōsus'', O.Ir. ''nert''), Gmc. *''ner''- (OHG ''Nerthus''), Bal. *''ner-/nor-'' (Lith. ''Nertėti'', O.Pruss. ''nertien'').
-*Obliques in *-''bh''- have been used, following the Italo-Celtic and Graeco-Aryan examples, against *-''m''- found in Germanic and Balto-Slavic, which is potentially influenced by a common substrate to both languages (see [[Corded Ware substrate hypothesis]]). The pronunciation of *-''bh''- in *u̯idn̥tbhós seems to be compelled by the preceding *-''t''- to be in *-''phos'' or *-''ɸos'', although an effort is made to pronounce it in a phonemically correct way.
+*Obliques in *-''bʰ''- have been used, following the Italo-Celtic and Graeco-Aryan examples, against *-''m''- found in Germanic and Balto-Slavic, which is potentially influenced by a common substrate to both languages (see [[Corded Ware substrate hypothesis]]). The pronunciation of *-''bʰ''- in *''u̯idn̥tbʰós'' seems to be compelled by the preceding *-''t''- to be in *-''pʰos'' or *-''ɸos'', although an effort is made to pronounce it in a phonemically correct way.
 *Aorists are reconstructed without augment in *''é-'', proper of Graeco-Aryan[Meier-Brügger 2003].
@@ Line 103: / Line 103: @@
 *Middle-passives are reconstructed in *-''r'', following the generalised belief of its older nature – as a primary ending in Anatolian and Tocharian –, and its reconstruction for Italo-Celtic, as well as remains with impersonal value in Germanic.
-*For present stem *''kl̥néu''-/''kl̥nu''-, ‘hear’, cf. O.Ir. ''ro-cluinethar'', Toch. B ''kalneṃ'', A ''kälniñc'', and also Skt. ''śr̥ṇóti'', Av. ''surunaoiti''. For verbal stem *''klu''-, frequently used when reconstructing the fable, the original meaning appears to be ‘be named, be renown’, cf. Av. ''sruiiē'', ‘be famous’, Lat. ''clueō'', ‘be named, be famous’, S.Picene ''kduíú'', ‘be named’[Kümmel et al. 2001]. The optional imperative suffix *-''dhí'' is not used.
+*For present stem *''kl̥néu''-/''kl̥nu''-, ‘hear’, cf. O.Ir. ''ro-cluinethar'', Toch. B ''kalneṃ'', A ''kälniñc'', and also Skt. ''śr̥ṇóti'', Av. ''surunaoiti''. For verbal stem *''klu''-, frequently used when reconstructing the fable, the original meaning appears to be ‘be named, be renown’, cf. Av. ''sruiiē'', ‘be famous’, Lat. ''clueō'', ‘be named, be famous’, S.Picene ''kduíú'', ‘be named’[Kümmel et al. 2001]. The optional imperative suffix *-''dʰí'' is not used.
-*Voiced consonants at the end of syllable (such as *-''d'', *-''gh''-, etc.) are pronounced voiced, because LIE or NWIE did not have final obstruent devoicing as a rule[Byrd 2010]. However, there are certain known cases of regressive assimilation, such as *DT→*TT, hence *''tod'' in the last sentence may be more exactly pronounced as *''tot-kekluu̯ṓs''.
+*Voiced consonants at the end of syllable (such as *-''d'', *-''gʰ''-, etc.) are pronounced voiced, because LIE or NWIE did not have final obstruent devoicing as a rule[Byrd 2010]. However, there are certain known cases of regressive assimilation, such as *DT→*TT, hence *''tod'' in the last sentence may be more exactly pronounced as *''tot-kekluu̯ṓs''.
 *We have selected the form *''ágros''[Ringe 2006][Nikolaev 2009] over the more ‘traditional’ *''agrós''.